For journal reviewers who need to explain what a manuscript does well and what needs work, get help assessing its argument, methods, evidence, and presentation. Paste a passage or summarize the paper, then ask for major concerns, actionable revision requests, or a brief note to the editor. Leave with comments authors can act on and an evaluation grounded in the manuscript material you share.
Reviewer Comments
Assess a manuscript and produce specific, balanced comments for peer review.
Use Reviewer Comments
$49.99 / month
Includes every Agent on Ai-GEN. 15,000+ Agents for one monthly price, cancel anytime.
From the creator of GPTs with 8.5M+ chats · 4.2 stars · 37K+ reviews
Start Reviewer Comments — $49.99 / month
Your account is created at checkout. After payment, this Agent opens when access is ready.
Already subscribed? Sign in · Account terms
Cancel future renewals from Account & Billing → Subscriptions.
What it writes
- Actionable major and minor reviewer comments
- Comments to the author
- Confidential note to the editor
How to use it
In your first message, name the journal’s review criteria, the paper’s central claim, and your top two concerns. Paste relevant excerpts so comments can point to the exact methods or evidence at issue.
What you bring
- Manuscript passage or paper summary
- Journal review criteria
- Your main concerns and strengths
- Remove author names if review is blind
A good fit for
- Reviewing a paper with major methods or evidence concerns
- Turning broad criticism into actionable requests for manuscript revision
- Preparing separate comments for authors and a confidential editor note
Ways to start
A few requests this Agent can handle.
I’m reviewing a clinical study with 84 participants and no control group. Help me assess whether the conclusions match the methods and write actionable major comments.
The paper claims its survey proves remote work increases productivity, but it reports only self-rated data from 112 employees. Help me phrase a balanced reviewer comment.
Write separate author comments and a confidential editor note for a paper with a useful research question but unclear sampling and missing limitations.
Good to know
This workspace provides text assistance.
- Making the accept or reject decision for you
- Replacing specialist judgment on complex methods
- Cannot verify claims or inspect a manuscript you do not paste
Before you subscribe
What am I buying?
One monthly subscription that opens this Agent and every other Agent on Ai-GEN. Cancel from Account & Billing.
What happens after payment?
Checkout creates or uses your Ai-GEN account. When payment and entitlement are confirmed, the purchased Agent opens. Choose a starter task, add your inputs, and send your first request.
Can I cancel?
Yes. Manage cancellation under Account & Billing → Subscriptions. Review the status and cancellation details shown there before confirming.
Can I use the response in my work?
Use it as a draft to review and adapt. Verify calculations, facts, rights, and suitability before relying on it. Do not provide information you do not have permission to share.
Report This Agent
Tell Ai-GEN about broken behavior, poor performance, misleading capabilities, or a safety concern.